This DELICIOUS Mushroom Barley Tomato Soup is the EASIEST way to go for the best umami results on a tight schedule. We want a umami flavored soup to remind us of the original Mushroom Barley comfort soup brought to New York Jewish Delis by Polish Jews, known in Yiddish as Krupnik.
While Krupnik contains meat, the original daily soup of the Shtetls in Eastern Europe was meat-free. As many couldn’t afford meat, they were constantly searching for ways to bypass poverty and prepare wholesome and filling dishes. Their lack of money was made up for by an abundance of resourcefulness.
According to the Jewish Daily Forward, the Jews used dried wild mushrooms to substitute for a meaty flavor in soups. Drying the mushrooms causes the break-down of their protein, thereby enhancing their umami flavor to make up for the lack of a meaty flavor.
So, let’s quickly go over these few ingredients in the recipe.
Ingredients
Tomatoes, carrots, mushrooms, and potatoes all contributre to the soup’s umami flavor.
Mushrooms –
Canned or raw. For raw mushrooms, just add them to the initail sauteing of the onions Suate for around 5 minutes over a high heat.
Onions –
Meatless soup always tastes the best to me when you begin the cooking process by sauteing or frying some chopped onion until they are translucent.
Carrots –
Diced carrots are sauteed to extract their sweetness and colors into the soup.
Parsely Leaves –
Chopped. Sub with cilantro leaves or minced celery leaves!
Tomatoes –
I love to fiddle with tomato contents. Sometimes I add freshly coarsely grated tomatoes, or cubed tomatoes. Other times, when I’m on a tight schedule, I’ll toss a can of crushed or cubed tomatoes and add to that tomato paste. While yet again, on other occasions I’ll alterante. I guess it just depends on my mood and on the flavors I imagine I will taste when the dish is ready. Feel free to do your own fiddling. If you choose raw tomatoes, add them to the frying/sauting of the onion, way before adding the water. For crushed tomatoes, and/or tomato paste, then just follow the instructions in the recipe below.
Pure Date Syrup –
I always add pure date syrup when I use sugar-free tomato contents and I need to add sweetness to rid of the bitter tang of the tomatoes. If you want sugar, just add a bit to taste.
Pearl barley –
Pearl barley is polished, or what’s known as ‘hulled’, where the outer (harder) bran is removed. This process reduces its cooking-time, which means that there is no need for a pre-soak to soften the grains.
For firmer vegetables and chewier barley grains, cook only 30-40 minutes from the initial boiling time. For softer barley, cook longer.
Kosher salt –
It’s unprocessed minerals add great flavors to any dish. I always prefer Kosher salt over table or sea salt as often as possible.
Black Pepper –
We add much more than called for in the recipe. It really depends on your preference.
Water –
You can add chicken stock or broth if having a vegan or pareve soup is of unimportance to you.
Lemon Juice –
If you want a bit of a sweet and sour tang. The amount you add is up to you. I’d suggest adding a bit more at a time while the soup is still simmering. Taste and adjust. Alternatively, you can eliminate the lemon juice all together.
If you have a non-stick pot, you’re in luck! You’d only need 2 tablespoons of oil for the entire recipe.
However, if not, follow the recipe instructions for more detailed info.
Equipment
- large high-rimmed non-stick pot
- ladle
- mixing spoon
- cutting board
- vegetable knife
Enjoy!
I’d love for you to share your thoughts in the comments section below.
You may also love…
Vegan Soups:
Vegan Split Peas Soup – Vintage
Hearty White Kidney (Cannallini) Bean Soup – Vegetarian
Meaty Soups:
Chicken Balls Soup – Persian Gondi
Nu
Mushroom Barley Tomato Soup On A Tight Schedule

Krupnik with tomatoes, minimum oil, easy prep, fresh-herb mushroom barley tomato soup with potatoes.
Ingredients
- 1/4 cup neutral oil
- 2 onions, chopped
- 4 cloves garlic, minced
- 2(8 oz.) cans sliced mushrooms (460 grams)
- 2 carrots, diced
- 1 cup chopped parsely leaves (or cilantro)
- 14 oz. can crushed/cubed tomatoes (400 grams)
- 1/2 cup tomato paste, sugar-free
- 2 Tablespoons pure date syrup
- 1 cup pearl barley
- 2½ teaspoons kosher salt and black pepper, to taste
- 2.70 quarts boiling water (2½ Liters)
- 1 teaspoon lemon juice
Instructions
- ½Rinsed barley over tiny holed strainer.
- Fry-mix vegetables and mushrooms in oil 10 minutes.
- Toss barley into pot.
- Add some of the salt, and the rest of the spices. Sauté 2 minutes.
- Pour canned tomatoes and paste into pot. Mix.
- Add water, boil, then mix and simmer 20 to 25 minutes.
- Adjust saltiness.
Notes
- A large high-rimmed NON-STICK pot. Medium size burner
- For softer, mushier barley, add 100 fluid ounces (3 liters) of water and cook for up to 15 more minutes.
- If tomato paste is SWEETENED, add less date syrup.
Nutrition Information
Yield
10Serving Size
1Amount Per Serving Calories 207Total Fat 1gSaturated Fat 0gTrans Fat 0gUnsaturated Fat 1gCholesterol 0mgSodium 532mgCarbohydrates 48gFiber 6gSugar 16gProtein 5g

Denise
Saturday 11th of February 2023
When I first arrived to visit Suzan, hungry and weary from my travels, this was the first of many wonderful meals she shared that I've had the privilege to eat. All of the delightful flavors and abundant variety of vegetables are perfectly balanced. I love this expression of sweet and sour. I was really craving some vegetables and this really hit the spot. This is now my favorite hearty vegetable barley soup. I'm excited to make this for my friends when I get home!
Suze
Saturday 11th of February 2023
Thanks, Denise for the lovely words! It was my pleasure! Enjoy the recipe! Let me know if you have any questions and how it came out! Send some pics! :)